Let some thoughts on Wikipedia, which I think is a good example of where too often lead the good intentions, hell is paved.
1) Unlike the most famous, popular, and used complex FOSS, Linux, the fact that there is no coordinator (Linus Torvalds for Linux) that gives the "OK" to exit the final broadcast of a core (kernel), or project teams who endorse the releases new versions as Apache or sendmail shows
demonstrates the usefulness of this validation process of diffusion.
In this sense that Wikipedia is the supreme example of free applied to the field of knowledge, my God, it would be like saying, yes I force the line which is not at all in my habits, that Anarchy is the model ultimede democracy.
It is true that things are going now or I end up asking me if you have not reached the limits of the model, the Iranian president's words "we have still not made a revolution for democracy" to cause it to have come to grow on reflection which is rather enlightened when one refers to shaping policy of near and middle east in the period 1910 1945. I think TE Lawrence and Louis Massignon (who had visions co trary) had guessed what would happen thereafter.
(See, eg, Louis Massignon, The Sheik admirable, published by the Capuchin for the second edition, or Massigon Plon for the first edition of Christian Destremau Moncelon Jean, and Lawrence of Arabia Henri Laurens discoveries in Gallimard). (Oil, again and again. The dramatic events related to Hurricane Katrina also demonstrated the fragility of globalization, disruption of oil production has enormous consequences. But we reassure the ice cap melting, new oilfields will be able be put into operation, which will enable us to accelerate a little more global warming, so the disappearance of the ice sheet and loop).
We all know the importance and prestige of scientific journals lies in their community reviewer, and it is certain areas or elsewhere could now be dispensed with entirely publisher-printers, especially
mathematical typesetting tools such as TeX / LaTeX, the adoption of Unicode by Windows XP, Free fonts of law, did not make a utopia. Besides this point, see the notebooks of Srinivasa Ramanujan, who died in 1920, then fell into the public domain are sold € 100 each by a publisher well-known scientific monopoly hurts my heart, it's treasure humanity and a layout along with some notes seem to extend the property, so I scan them and I'll put on the internet I would likely culprit in the eyes of the PLI / PLA ETDE protection of copyright.
Passing on Ramanujan's obituary appeared in the annals of the British Mathematical Society is available at Gallica: http://gallica.bnf.fr/document?O=N056192 (Proceedings of the Royal Society, 1921, 99, p . XII-XXIX.). So
Wikipedia free model no. Model limitations and dangers of good intentions, yes.
2) I consulted Wikipedia for me to re-get an idea on four topics that I know a little.
Hepatitis C: two major errors (use of condoms, reversible side effects due to treatment by stopping this one). This is not what people are saying now quite numerous global conferences on the subject of consensus.
(Other errors confusion between chronic and acute, et al).
Worse in my opinion in the process, there are two external links that have the merit to specify the date of publication, but either we make an approach to a bibliography (which is still a minimum in an article popular science), it may not be exhaustive, but can not be reduced to two links!
For example, consensus conferences are online dating.
Biography Octave Mannoni. If properly refers to his book "Psychology of Colonization" controversy and criticism of his position made by Aimé Césaire and Frantz Fanon are simply ignored.
It does not matter except to suggest that his position was welcomed as a major advance in understanding the phenomenon from a psychological point of view ethno-logic machine.
Biography of Maud Mannoni: The School of Bonneuil never been founded with her husband.
The article on Jung ignores the period 1933-1937 where he was head of the German Psychoanalytic Society, and sentence: "We expect all our members that they have scientifically read" Mein Kampf "
and accepts as a base."
(In Linguing Shadows Shambreal, Boston & London, 1991
it is clear that the phrase
"The Society Expects all members Who Work as writers or speakers to work-through Afolf Hitler's Mein Kampf WITH ALL Scientific efforts and accept as it has basis "is published in the international edition of the company which Jung had the Presidency in its edition of December 1933.
On anti-Semitism of Jung, the Eleventh International Congress of Jungian psy (IAAP) held in Paris in 1989, concludes:
general acceptance
There Was That history (Jung) anti-Semitic WAS Behavior. I Think It Is clear it has taken to Jungian Collectively Fifty Years Begin the process in earnest. Jerome S Bernstein Jewish Jungian psychologist. They call
Jungian School of Zurich to a duty of memory.
Good, bad Jung did not like the cathos in the archives of the Countway Library of Medicine, Faculty of Medicine at Harvard, there are interviews with Jacobi in the journal Jolande ABJ (Jung's biographical archives December 23, 1989): "Jung sent me a furious letter learning
my decision to convert to Catholicism. Nobody's premises of mine who is in the Church. You'll have your confessor. I am for people who are outside the Church. "
I stopped.
So in my opinion Wikipedia is like the Internet, you can find anything and everything.
There is the possibility of re-writing history, not to convey that the official story, etc..
If the etymology comes from the Greek (ἑγκύκλιος παιαδεία) to set up a complete education, we really can not say that in this sense it is an encyclopedia, except to re-consider education as formatting time
available brain.
All this is quite reassuring: we can not dispense with the editorial board, editorial line, for scientific validation. In the same way that the search "full text" at hand offer a lot of noise does not make sense for a library reasoned (and not a pile of books).
And it's not the idea (which still share a good intent) of the Semantic Web by Tim Berners-Lee (see http://www.urfist.cict.fr/lettres/lettre28/lettre28- 22.html) that will fix things.
See what it is to wake up early on a Sunday, we have moods ... 
0 comments:
Post a Comment